Chapter 2
Chapter 2: The Year of the Locked Door
The year Priya left, Ananya was fifteen, and the house learned a new kind of silence.
It wasn't loud, the leaving. That was the part that surprised her, looking back — she'd expected slammed doors, a dramatic scene worthy of the films Kavitha Auntie's daughter watched on loop, but what actually happened was smaller and worse. A note on the kitchen table. A suitcase that had clearly been packed for days, hidden somewhere Ananya never found. A phone call from her father's cousin in Pune, three days later, confirming what everyone had already guessed: Priya had married Arjun — a boy from a different community, a different tax bracket, a boy their parents had met exactly once and disapproved of within four minutes — in a small registrar's office, with two witnesses who were not family.
What followed was not a fight. It was worse than a fight. It was eleven months of her mother not saying Priya's name out loud, of relatives who stopped visiting, of her father developing a tightness in his chest that the doctor diagnosed as stress and everyone else diagnosed as heartbreak, of birthday cards that arrived from Pune and were left, unopened, in a drawer in the hallway table that nobody ever mentioned and everybody knew about.
Ananya had been the one home when it happened. Fifteen years old, doing homework at the kitchen table, watching her mother read the note three times before her hands started shaking. She remembered thinking, with the specific clarity children sometimes have about consequences they don't yet understand: whatever this costs, I am never doing it.
She had kept that promise for three years. She had gotten so good at keeping it that she'd started to forget it was a promise at all, rather than simply who she was.
The strangest part, looking back, was how quickly the house had reorganized itself around the absence — how a family of five effectively became a family of three overnight, with Priya's name surviving only in oblique references, in the careful way her mother would say "before, when things were different" instead of naming what had actually changed. Ananya had watched her parents' grief calcify into something that looked, from the outside, like moving on, and had learned, without anyone teaching her directly, that the fastest way to keep a household from breaking further was to never again give it a reason to hold its breath.
She'd tried, once, in the third month after Priya left, to ask her mother if they could call her. Just to check she was safe. Her mother's face had done something Ananya had never seen it do before or since — not anger, not sadness exactly, but a kind of visceral flinch, as though the question itself was a wound being pressed on directly.
"When she is ready to come back to this family properly," her mother had said, voice tight, "we will speak. Until then, we do not chase people who have chosen to leave us."
Ananya had never asked again. She'd found other ways to keep tabs on her sister instead — a secret social media account Priya didn't know she followed, the occasional message exchanged when their mother was out of the house, a birthday card sent each year from Ananya alone, unsigned by anyone else in the family, that she hoped Priya understood as the small, insufficient bridge it was meant to be.
It was during that first terrible year, the year of the locked drawer and her father's careful new silence, that she found NEON PULSE.
It happened the way these things happen — a video that autoplayed after something else, a stranger's face on a screen at two in the morning when she couldn't sleep because the house felt too quiet in the specific way houses feel when everyone in them is pretending not to be sad. She almost scrolled past it. She had never had any particular interest in performance, in choreography, in seven boys in matching outfits doing something that looked, from the outside, like exactly the kind of frivolous nonsense her mother would have rolled her eyes at.
Then the lead vocalist stepped forward for his line, and something about his voice — rough at the edges, deliberately imperfect in a way that felt more true than the polished parts around it — made her sit up in bed at two in the morning and play it again.
She fell down the archive after that. Every interview. Every behind-the-scenes clip. Every fan translation of every lyric, because she quickly discovered that this particular member wrote most of what he sang, and that the writing said things she had no other outlet for saying herself.
There was a song — not their biggest one, buried on an album most casual listeners skipped past — called, in the fan translations she found, something close to Unfinished Portrait. It was about being loved for the parts of yourself that didn't perform well. About being seen, fully, including the ugly unpolished parts, and being kept anyway. She played it on repeat on the walk to school every morning for the better part of a year, because it was the only place in her entire life, at fifteen, where someone seemed to be saying: you don't have to earn this. You are allowed to just be a mess and still be worth staying for.
Nobody in her actual house was saying that to her. Everybody in her actual house was, without meaning to, saying the opposite — that love in this family was conditional on being easy, on being managed, on never once causing the kind of seismic event Priya had caused. She didn't blame them for it. She understood, even then, that they were frightened people doing frightened things. But understanding it didn't make the loneliness of it any smaller, and a stranger's voice in her earphones, three thousand miles away, singing about being loved unconditionally, became the only unconditional thing in her life.
She started the binder that same year. Forty-two cards now, though it had started with three — cheap fan-made prints she'd bought off a resale account with money meant for lunch, because owning something physical made the whole thing feel less like a coping mechanism and more like a collection, which felt, at fifteen, like an important distinction to preserve.
She remembered the exact afternoon she bought the first card — a rainy Tuesday, her mother out at a relative's condolence visit, the house achingly quiet in the way it had been quiet for months. She'd sat on her bedroom floor with the small plastic-sleeved photograph in her hands, studying the face of a stranger who had, without knowing it, become the only reliably kind voice in her entire world, and had felt something she hadn't let herself feel since the note appeared on the kitchen table: the specific, unguarded relief of being allowed to want something small and frivolous and completely her own, with no family reputation riding on the outcome.
She'd hidden that first card inside a maths textbook — the same textbook, coincidentally, that would eventually carry her concert ticket three years later, as though some part of her had always understood exactly where the safest hiding places in her own house were located. By the time she'd added the fifth card, she understood she was building something more permanent than a passing interest. By the time she'd added the twentieth, she'd stopped pretending, even to herself, that it was anything other than the architecture of a private self her family had never been invited to meet.
Meher found out about it in their second week of engineering college, when she walked into Ananya's hostel room unannounced and caught her mid-binder-reorganization, which Ananya did periodically the way some people reorganized spice racks.
"Okay," Meher had said, dropping her bag, taking in the scene with the specific delighted horror of someone who has just found her people. "We are going to be very good friends, and also I need you to see my Astra Nine folder, because I think we might actually be the exact same unwell."
It was Meher who'd helped her open the account two years ago. Meher who'd done the maths with her, working out exactly how many months of skipped lunches and pocketed allowance it would take to afford the ticket, the bus fare, the whole reckless architecture of a plan neither of their families could ever know about. Meher who'd said, the day the ticket finally came through, "You know this is the least insane thing you've ever wanted, right? You've wanted this for three years and told literally nobody. That's not obsession, Ananya. That's just what want looks like when you've been trained not to have any."
Ananya hadn't fully believed her at the time.
The saving itself had been its own quiet education in patience. She'd taken on tutoring two neighborhood children in mathematics every Tuesday and Thursday for a year, telling her mother it was "for the resume," and had funneled every rupee of it into the account Meher had helped her open at a bank branch two towns over, specifically chosen because no one in it would ever recognize the Iyer name and mention it in passing to Kavitha at a wedding. She'd skipped the annual college fest t-shirt two years running, claiming she found the design ugly, when the truth was simpler: four hundred rupees not spent was four hundred rupees closer to a stadium seat. She'd worn the same three pairs of jeans for the better part of two years, mending them herself badly, because new jeans were a want she could postpone and the concert was not.
It had felt, at the time, less like sacrifice and more like devotion — the specific, disciplined devotion of someone building a cathedral one brick at a time, in secret, knowing that the person the cathedral was built for would never know it existed. She used to lie in bed some nights doing the math backward, calculating exactly how many tutoring sessions stood between her and the ticket, and the number, whatever it was that week, had always felt like the only countdown in her life she'd chosen for herself rather than inherited from someone else's plan.
"You're doing the face," Meher had said once, catching her mid-calculation over a hostel dinner of instant noodles. "The counting face. You've done it since first year."
"What face?"
"The one where you're doing arithmetic on something that actually matters to you, instead of arithmetic that's going to be on an exam. It's the only time you look like you're not performing being fine. I like the face. I wish you did it more often about things that weren't secret."
Ananya hadn't had a good answer for that then, either, and she thought about it now — the accuracy of it, the specific loneliness of being seen so clearly by exactly one person in an entire university, while an entire family two hundred kilometers away remained convinced she had no interior life at all beyond the one they'd assigned her.
There had been one close call, in the second year of saving, that had nearly ended the whole plan before it began. Her mother, doing a routine sweep of Ananya's room in search of a missing dupatta, had found the binder itself — not hidden well enough, tucked under a stack of notebooks rather than properly concealed — and had stood in the doorway holding it when Ananya came home from tutoring, her expression unreadable in a way that had made Ananya's stomach drop straight through the floor.
"What is this," her mother had said. Not a question, really. A demand for an explanation that didn't yet exist.
"It's just — a hobby. Music. Everyone has one." Ananya had reached for it, and her mother had let her take it, watching with an expression that flickered, briefly, into something almost like recognition before resettling into its usual careful neutrality.
"You spend money on this?"
"Some. Not much." A lie, delivered with the smooth, practiced ease of three years of exactly this kind of self-protective editing.
Her mother had looked at the binder a moment longer, at the careful plastic sleeves, the corners gone soft from handling, and then, unexpectedly, had simply nodded and left the room without further comment — no lecture, no confiscation, nothing beyond that single flicker of something unspoken passing behind her eyes.
Ananya had spent that entire night rebuilding her hiding places with the paranoid thoroughness of someone who'd nearly lost everything, moving the binder to the bottom of a stack of engineering textbooks specifically chosen because her mother had zero interest in fluid dynamics, and had never fully understood, until years later, standing in a village courtyard telling a masked stranger this same story, that her mother's silence that day had not been indifference. It had been recognition — the specific, complicated recognition of a woman who understood exactly what it looked like to keep a small, unauthorized want hidden in the corners of a life that had no room budgeted for it, because she had been doing the same thing herself for thirty years and had simply never told anyone.
She thought about it now, sitting at the dining table across from a boy named Karthik who was describing, for the third time, the specific merits of his car, and felt the binder's weight in her bag like a held breath, and understood, with sudden, total clarity, that whatever happened in the next two hours, she was getting on that bus.
She had spent three years being loved conditionally by people who meant well. She was owed, at minimum, one afternoon of being unconditionally, recklessly, entirely herself — even if the only place that self had ever been allowed to exist freely was in a locked bedroom at two in the morning, listening to a stranger's voice tell her she didn't have to earn the right to be a mess.
Enjoying this story?
Continue reading by creating a free account.